Conclusion
Dickens, because of his keen awareness of
his
audience's
general beliefs, was able to use in David
Copperfield
popular religious typology to help unify the
novel
as well as assist it in its delivery of his social
message. Using the Christian's expectations about
every
individual's loss and reclamation, Dickens forms a
pattern
which he repeats several times and on different
levels
throughout the work, artistically bringing
together
a wide variety of characters to emphasize his
social
concept of benevolent interaction.
The most obvious example of the loss and
reclamation
pattern in David Copperfield is the story of
Little
Em'ly who is seduced by David's aristocratic
friend
Steerforth, is sought throughout Europe by her
loving
uncle, Daniel Peggotty, escapes from "sin"
herself
when she realizes she has been deceived, makes
her way
back to London where she falters, and is
restored
to her Uncle Daniel's fellowship, thanks
especially
to one individual, Martha, whom Em'ly had
shown
mercy upon herself years before. Em'ly
is then
able to
start a new and redeemed life in Australia.
From her experience, underlined by
various
religious
references used by Dickens, several character
types
become clear who play out the pattern of a pilgrim
making
his or her way through life. The
pattern is
based
on basic biblical types as well as expectations
created
by Pilgrim's Progress, and goes as follows: The
pilgrim
begins in grace. Because of a weakness
in his
or her
self-vision, the pilgrim is vulnerable to a
channel
of perdition. Because of the influence
of
perdition,
the pilgrim falls. The pilgrim
recognizes
the
fall, repents, and demonstrates this repentance by
attempting
to be in some manner or another a channel of
grace
to another individual. Although too
weak to
effect
a complete restoration alone, the pilgrim changes
direction
and finds assistance in channels of grace who
form a
net of benevolent interdependence. The
pilgrim
is
restored and the faulty vision of self renewed.
This basic pattern finds multiple
versions within
David
Copperfield's plot, ranging in tone from the
dramatic
to the comic. Some examples of pilgrims
besides
Little Em'ly are Martha, Mr. Wickfield, Mrs.
Strong,
Mr. Micawber, and Mrs. Gummidge.
Although their
plot-lines
are very different, yet the pattern in each
life
displays the same basic elements described above.
What is remarkable is that while
following this
pattern,
Dickens never becomes simplistic or trite in
his
presentation of individual characters.
Through
their
stories he is able to examine personal problems
caused
by social elitism, alcoholism, non-communication
in
marriages, economic mismanagement and self pity.
As mentioned, the story of Em'ly because
of its use
of
religious references awakens the reader to the
existence
of the pattern of loss and reclamation.
These
many
other characters also use religious images, if not
so
consistently, continuing the pattern.
Once the reader is aware of these cycles in the
novel,
it then also becomes clear that the main
character,
David Copperfield himself has also passed
through
the cycle of loss and reclamation not once but
several
times. Within his narrative there seems
to be
at
least five times when his soul, or his vision of
himself,
is in jeopardy. And in each case, a
channel of
grace
steps forward to pull him back.
When David is a child, it is the hand of
his nurse,
Clara
Peggotty who affirms his worth when it is badly
wounded
by his abusive step-father, Murdstone.
As a boy
abandoned
in London, it is the kindness he has heard
about
his Aunt Betsey which encourages David to make his
way to
Canterbury where she helps him start a new life
and
leave behind the poverty of a working existence at a
bottling
factory as well as the wretched education he
received
from the sadistic Mr. Creakle in Salem House.
When
David is a young man, his childhood friend Agnes is
able to
sharpen his perception of the nature belonging
to his
best and most dangerous friend, Steerforth, so
that he
does not fall into the trap of measuring all of
humanity
(especially himself) by social rank.
When he
is
married, his Aunt stops him from becoming in his
behavior
to his silly but sweet wife, Dora, the
repressive
type of husband his own step-father had been
to his
mother. And when he finally loses
through death
his
wife, an old companion, and his dearest friend,
Agnes
reaches out in a letter and pulls him away from a
despairing
vision of the universe controlled by
randomness. Although exceeding his wildest hopes, David
discovers
that Agnes loves him romantically, and so
David
is able to recreate the lost home shattered by
Murdstone
years before. Thus, David's life seems
to be
a
confirmation that providential grace is a part of
human
existence.
What is also apparent, however, is the
fact that it
is
David himself who is, in the re-telling of his life,
emphasizing
(and maybe creating) the pattern he seems to
need to
find. This raises the suggestion of an
unspoken
crisis
in the narrator's life which requires the
assurance
of providential care, and there is organic
evidence
in the text that the crisis may be David's own
impending
death.
However, it should be pointed out that
while death
is very
likely David's last crisis, the pattern of loss
and
reclamation which Agnes embodies, deals with far
more
than just David's fear of discontinuance.
David
has had
some terrible experiences. There is
injustice
and
misery in his world which is sometimes never undone.
Murdstone
may be reported to be miserable, but he is
flourishing
as he bears down on another young wife.
The
mere fact that Murdstone was able to get into
Clara
Copperfield's life at all raises questions about
"the
mysterious dispensations of Providence" (213). Mr.
Creakle
may be laughable in his belief in his reform
prison
system, yet no one repays him for the cruelty he
inflicted
upon the boys under his charge. Ham is
never
recompensed
for his loss but instead dies in a futile
attempt
to save the destroyer of his own happiness.
The
list
continues.
What David seems to suggest is that
having attained
the
happiness he has found with Agnes, he affirms a
pattern
which supports the belief in providential grace.
Even
the terrible events which make up his life are
redeemed
in that they are now the source of wisdom he
now
expresses in his writing. So, in spite
of all the
pain
which David has endured he is able to say like St.
Paul
"that the final outcome is of worth for "where sin
abounded,
grace did much more abound" (Rom. 5:20 KJV).
David's religious point of view should
not be
confused
as Dickens' perspective. For Dickens,
the
particular
nature of beliefs of an individual would not
be as
important as how those beliefs affect a person's
response
to those around him or her. In David
Copperfield,
the Murdstone faith dominates and crushes,
the
Heep faith allows subterfuge, but the faith
exemplified
by Clara and Daniel Peggotty, Agnes
Wickfield,
Betsey Trotwood and eventually incorporated
by
David which advocates that salvation is possible when
individuals
choose to function as channels of grace for
one
another. To this view, Dickens
subscribed whole-
heartedly.